Followers

Friday, 19 May 2017

What If.


I have posted various articles about Northern Ireland’s potential as an activity tourist destination. Now I think the time is right to start to look at the specifics, particularly a deep dive into the potential of those regions which have all the right ingredients to turn them into outdoor activity meccas. You know the type of place I’m talking about, those areas blessed with fabulous scenery combined with the infrastructure to take advantage should we ever get it together and start to fully exploit the untapped potential literally staring everyone in the face.

There probably won’t be any surprises here. Northern Ireland is a small place, yet contains an amazing variety of scenery. Certain audience sectors of the tourism market are already pretty well catered for, so most of the places I’ll look at will already have fairly well developed tourism infrastructure, at least by Northern Ireland standards; there is no comparison to be made with wider UK, Ireland, or European tourism. What will become apparent, however, is that the outdoor activity sector is by and large mainly untapped, and that its growth is being resolutely strangled and curtailed by poor access legislation.  It will become obvious that, with a bit of imagination and political courage/will, the economic and social benefits payoff to 'cutting away the red tape', so to speak, could be huge.

We’ll take each area in turn, and centre analysis round the key ‘gateway’ towns and villages. For example, think about the English Lake District. Ok, a big area and the ultimate example of how countryside access is completely intertwined with the local economy. Now what are the key ‘gateway’ destinations in this area; those places with shops, accommodation, services etc. which can cater for large number of tourists. Effectively, what are the main hubs in this area which people flock to, even if their main goal is to enjoy a weekend or a week of walking, canoeing, or mountain biking? It is an easy answer if you know the area - Keswick, Ambleside, Windermere-Bowness, Coniston, Hawkshead. You get the idea.

Except in Northern Irish terms, no area is as well developed as the Lake District. There are multiple reasons why this should be, but the biggest is single fact that the countryside of the Lake District is accessible in a way that no part of Northern Ireland currently is. Its whole economy is built on the bedrock of accessibility, catering for a wide variety of differing markets; mountaineers who want to climb the highest peaks, hill walkers who want to walk across the hills for most of the day, to families and pensioners who are happy wandering a wood, strolling around a lake, or rambling a river bank path.

Some of the gateway areas might seem obvious, but others are less so due to a number of reasons, but mainly due to a lamentable lack of countryside access locally, combined with a failure to recognise potential and subsequently develop and exploit it.


The main areas I will look at over a long series of articles are as follows:

North Antrim Coast and Glens

Strangford and Ards Peninsula

The Mournes and Slieve Croob

Fermanagh Lakelands

The Sperrins and Binevenagh

Lough Neagh and The River Bann

There is a fairly eclectic mix of landscape represented across these six regions. Some are doing better than others when it comes to activity tourism. We can look at why this is so (clue, might have something to do with the amount of formally accessible countryside). The last area listed, Lough Neagh and the Bann, isn’t a region as such I suppose, given that the Bann flows for 90 miles north though the centre of Northern Ireland, but it seemed a natural fit to group them together for what I hope are fairly obvious reasons.

Sunday, 6 March 2016

Greenway Dash

While the countryside legislation situation in the Rep of Ireland remains stubbornly in stasis, the last couple of years have seen an absolute explosion in the development or proposed development of 'greenways' across the country. This is very welcome and reflects a growing understanding, especially in rural communities, of the benefits which are to be had from great countryside access, for both walker and cyclists. The noted (if, at least to this observer, entirely predictable) success of the Great Western Greenway in County Mayo has caused the country to sit up and take notice it would seem.

While greenways in themselves are not an alternative to wider countryside access, they can form another step in the continuing development of the countryside access situation in the Republic of Ireland. It also paints the tantalising prospect of an Ireland whereby local people are facilitated to travel much more by bike and on foot between towns and villages, leading to much reduced carbon emissions and a healthier population as well. The social benefits are almost endless.


A number of projects are now coming together, and in a surprisingly short period of time. A quick google search quickly reveals how many greenways are already underway.

http://www.deisegreenway.com
http://www.galwaytodublincycleway.ie/
http://candlgreenway.ie/
http://www.southerntrail.net/
http://www.irishgreenways.com/


Of course such progress across practically all parts of the country has met some pockets of resistance. The Irish Farmers Association continues to be predictably resistant to any initiative that seeks to open up the countryside to recreational users, and the rise of the greenway has drawn their ire in particular. Still a formidably powerful political force, they have managed to throw a spanner in the works of the Dublin to Galway project for instance.

Still, one gets the impression that they are very much fighting against the tide of history and that they are losing the argument with the general public. As speaker after speaker stands up in the Dail to demand that funding is made available for such greenways in their part of the country, it is only because they are being heavily lobbied by their constituents.



Coastal Path Proposal - Kilkeel to Ballyhalbert

I picked this little article up in the local paper, and it certainly piqued my interest. Ambitious in scope, the project proposes a continuous coastal path from Kilkeel to Ballyhalbert. The idea is a good one, obviously inspired by the coastal path projects going on across the water in Scotland, Wales, and now England. The problems it faces are, however, depressingly familiar and stem from the fact that our countryside access laws are not fit for purpose. The economic benefits of countryside access are a large part of why proposals such as these come to light in the first place, but unless our politicians in Stormont actually reform the legislative framework in a progressive manner, bringing us into line with the rest of the UK, then such initiatives may fail because of resistance from landowners with a misplaced fear of allowing recreational users onto their land.

Another issue is that, while called the 'Mourne and Strangford Lough Coastal Walking Path', the project actually chooses to mostly ignore the potential offered by the coastline of Strangford Lough, and instead routes itself along the eastern coastline of the Ards. Parts of this coastline are of course very scenic, especially that part running from Portaferry to Kearney. However, the Strangford Lough coastline, in my humble opinion, is overall a more scenic area and offers the prospect of a truly world class multi-day long-distance path. But perhaps it's a case of one step at a time! If this proposal can be realised and is successful, then the case for other coastal paths is much more easily made.






Sunday, 25 January 2015

Mount Stewart

It was great to hear this week that the National Trust has acquired the whole of the Mount Stewart Estate. They previously only owned the house and gardens, and it has always been somewhat frustrating as a regular visitor that the rest of the estate was essentially 'out of bounds' to mere oiks such as myself.

With this near one thousand acre procurement, the Trust will be able to create a beacon of countryside access on the Ards Peninsula. Indeed, those pieces of coast or countryside on the Ards which are accessible tend to be owned and managed by the National Trust, such as Kearney, Nugents Wood,or Ballyquentin Farm.

Up to now, barring those mentioned above, the Ards has been an area severely lacking in countryside access opportunities. This has meant it has a relatively under-developed tourism economy. Visitors tend to drive the coast road to Mount Stewart, carry on to Portaferry and then get the ferry to Strangford. As with much of Northern Ireland, the area has loads of potential, but local politicians have little vision. The result is a rural economy which has badly stagnated.
.

Sunday, 12 October 2014

Offas Dyke

It's been a few weeks since we returned from walking Offa's Dyke Path. It was a great holiday, and one of the best long distant paths we've walked to date. We got lucky with the weather, no doubt about that. This allowed us to enjoy this stunning walk at its finest.

Straddling the Welsh/English border, the ODP is around 177 miles long, running from Chepstow in the south to Prestatyn in the north. It was everything we hoped it would be and more, a great trail in every sense. There were so many highlights: walking high above the Wye Valley, striding across the Black Mountains, the mythical landscape of Hergest Ridge, Powis Castle, and on it goes: brilliant!

The holiday also confirmed once again that which seems obvious to all but our local politicians and farming community - that countryside access is of massive benefit to rural communities. It was very apparent that a lot of people rely on the business generated by the ODP, thereby ensuring that isolated rural communities have a chance to survive if not indeed thrive. The Offa's Dyke Path is like a giant artery pumping lifeblood into the communities it passes through, having a very real and positive impact on people's lives.


















Friday, 23 May 2014

Prime Time Debate

The recent debate on countryside access on the RTE current affairs programme Prime Time shed rather more heat than light on the issue. While predictably disappointing it was still very encouraging that it took place at all. It surely reflects the fact that as an issue, countryside access is rising up the political agenda in the Republic of Ireland.

Memo to KIO: stay positive and don't allow yourselves to be painted as some appallingly radical group. As this programme showed, some landowners/farmers like to portray themselves as the victims, and there is a risk that those proposing progressive and sensible access reforms for the benefit of all, come across as urban bully boys who want nothing but to trample all over crops, damage fences and walk through farmhouse kitchens (while sacrificing their first born to boot). I'm not saying this happened here, but you get my drift...

Define what access actually means and then keep the message simple. After that hit the 3 main points:

1 Countryside access legislation does not mean the end of days and works perfectly well the world over. Rights of private landowners cannot trump wider society requirements and landowners are well compensated by the taxpayer via EU grants.

2 Countryside access legislation will fully unlock the potential of the countryside. It will bring massive economic benefits to local rural economy, something which will allow local people to get better jobs and give them an opportunity to live in the area they were brought up in. Farmers sons and daughters will be among those to benefit.

3 Countryside access will be of massive benefit to local communities, giving people access to their own  as it reduces car usage , allows rural people, including children, to walk safely between destinations, and improves health outcomes - which again leads to savings for society in terms of coping with obesity and associated illness etc.

Also, keep lots of stats and examples handy to backup the argument.

Sunday, 23 February 2014

A powerful ally?

It was good to see the Belfast Telegraph giving countryside access issues a bit of coverage. First it covered the welcome ruling by the court to force a landowner to open the King John's Highway in Holywood County Down.

Next it covered another piece of good news on the local countryside access front.

Finally it had a more general piece on the poor countryside access legislation Northern Ireland is currently lumbered with. Once again, kudos goes to Ulster Federation of Rambling Clubs.

This could indicate a growing interest by the press in this issue . The Telegraph has a long history of campaigning on progressive issues, and it would be a powerful ally in any campaign to pressurise our politicians into reshaping our countryside access laws for the better.

Sunday, 26 January 2014

Cliffs of Moher path development

Congrats to all involved in the development of the new cliff path along the sensational Cliffs of Moher in County Clare.

Despite being a seemingly obvious thing, (remember that Wales has a path around its entire coastline which is reaping huge benefits for local economies) familiar Irish style access issues had been bedevilling the word famous Clare coastline for years. Of course, given the cliffs iconic status, the sheer weight of tourist numbers made it practically impossible for objecting landowners to do much about people walking their length, except to erect unwelcoming GOML type signs - not a very constructive thing for an area whose economy depends on tourism to such a large extent.

Now everyone concerned seems to have recognised that embracing the potential of the cliffs is the best approach for both landowners and the local economy as a whole. It has taken much work and negotiation, something which better countryside access laws might have negated the need for. But we are where we are and it is good to see a bottom up community approach bear such fruit. Landowners will hopefully come to see that no threat is posed by countryside access, but can be to the benefit of everyone in the local community. Walkers do not wish to trample over the countryside, but instead wish well defined routes to enable them to traverse it without fear of upsetting anyone.

Landscapes such as the Cliff of Moher deserve to be accessible to all, and such enlightened development deserves to be rewarded and lauded as an example to all. Here's hoping it can be sustained and that the model can not only be repeated, but can eventually inspire much needed change in the countryside access laws of the Republic of Ireland.


Sunday, 1 December 2013

Re-Using old railway lines

I came across this excellent blog site while casually browsing the Interweb recently. As both a walker and a cyclist, I think that this is a great idea that should be heartily supported. These old lines could form an important building block in the countryside network infrastructure that needs to be developed in Northern Ireland. They could be used  as paths and trails for recreational users, and also by local people and children travelling safely between towns and villages - well away from dangerous country roads. Politicians take note.

Wild Nephin

Amidst the depressing lack of progress on countryside access legislation, both north and south, sometimes you hear about something that just brightens your day up a little. The Wild Nephin project is a brilliant idea, and will hopefully become a model that can be repeated across the island and beyond.


Saturday, 23 November 2013

Shooting yourself in the foot, Part 1...

The recent decision by the Environment Minister, Mark H Durkan, to shelve National Parks legislation is as disheartening as it was inevitable. Given the whipped up hysteria against the legislation, mainly by the UFU, it was only a matter of time before our politicians pandered to the least common denominator and pulled the rug from underneath the one progressive and potentially massively beneficial piece of legislation that the Executive had come up with.

The UFU were predictable in their reaction. Yet such a response is again a startlingly self-defeating one. A wilful refusal to explore or recognise any benefit in National Parks, and the potential diverse economic opportunities such legislation could bring to farmers and land owners, is in the long run a complete dis-service to the people they purport to represent.

It again underlines the fact that the UFU still have to recognise that the rural economy can only thrive if non-farming sectors are given the space to do so. Rural communities are in the main made up of people who do not own land. Sustainable job creation in such areas, which would enable young people to stay and raise families where they were born, rather than move away, can only occur if our legislators create the conditions whereby investment can be made in sustainable rural sectors of employment. National Parks would provide a framework of protections for our most beautiful countryside areas, and also the access frameworks required to encourage much needed investment into them.

Saying all that, advocates of national parks and progressive countryside legislation in general, including those in the tourism sector, need to up their game and start to be more politically savvy. Things won't change all by themselves and the message needs to be better communicated. Those who oppose national parks may be misguided, but once again they have shown that they are better organised and more motivated in their campaign of opposition and lobbying. Dismantling their arguments and getting across a positive vision for the Northern Irish countryside is the challenge before us all.

Sunday, 10 November 2013

Media Interest

It's been a while since I last posted. I'm going to get back at it again, but I thought I should make a quick comment on a little article on countryside access that ran on Radio Ulster the other morning. It was about a right of way being blocked off by developers in the village of Broughshane, a village located outside Ballymena, and the fact that local people had cried foul and were attempting to have it reinstated. Good for them, hopefully it'll be open again before too long.

However, the second half of the article featured an interview with representatives. While the interviewer appeared clueless about the wider issues involved, the Ulster Ramblers rep (Alan McFarland I think, but I could be wrong - Update: turns out it was David Flinn - see comment below) did a nice job, with the limited time available, of drawing a contrast between the situation in GB and in Northern Ireland, especially in relation to activity tourism and the economic benefits that countryside access is bringing there.

By contrast, the Ulster Farmers representative didn't even attempt to engage at that level, instead listing the risks that farmers would face if people got access to their land. It was a rather depressing contribution. In an economic environment that is downright awful, especially in rural areas, the UFU guy displayed a complete lack of imagination or willingness to see any positive benefit to greater countryside access. This highlights the job of work that countryside activity advocates have to do in order to make progress with the farming and landowner types.

Again, David did nice job of arguing how a structured countryside access framework could actually minimise risk to landowners by making it clear where people can and cannot go (PRoWs do this very nicely). He also covered the recent unsuccessful attempt to reform the landowners liability legislation.

Sunday, 16 June 2013

Some Interesting Facts...

Walking is by far the biggest activity-based tourism activity in Ireland, attracting 743,000 overseas visitors, four times more than golf, which is the second largest activity. (Fáilte Ireland, 2012)


According to a recent estimate, Scotland generates £1.4bn from nature-based tourism (Bryden, Westbrook, Burns , Taylor , & Anderson, 2010).

By 2015 walking tourism is projected to account for 22pc of Scotland’s tourism revenue. (Tourism Intelligence Scotland)

Evidence from Fife in Scotland shows that the Fife Coastal Path contributes between €24m and €29m to the local economy, supporting the equivalent of 800-900 full time jobs. (TNS Travel and Tourism & SQW, 2006)

Based on this data and similar case studies, we estimate that if Irish land access laws are similarly modernised, hundreds of jobs could be created in the tourism sector in the medium term.

Walking is by far the largest activity-based form of tourism in Ireland – attracting projected to account for 22% of Scotland’s tourism revenue. (Tourism Intelligence Scotland) Evidence from Fife in Scotland shows that the Fife Coastal Path contributes between €24m and €29m to the local economy, supporting the equivalent of 800-900 full time jobs. (TNS Travel and Tourism & SQW, 2006)

Based on this data and similar case studies, we estimate that if Irish land access laws are similarly modernised, hundreds of jobs could be created in the tourism sector in the medium term.

Surveys suggest that Ireland’s scenery is a huge draw for overseas visitors to Ireland, but much of it remains inaccessible. (Fáilte Ireland , 2010) (Buckley, Hynes, & van Rensburg, 2008)

Contrary to common perceptions, hikers and walkers spend significant amounts: the average spend per person among hikers and walkers in 2011 was €873. (Fáilte Ireland, 2012)

As landowners have discretion to deny access, a wide network of well-documented walking routes has not been established. Many walking routes are on roads rather than land and lack of signage leaves tourists confused about where they are allowed to walk. Taking these factors combined, Ireland currently offers a walking tourism product which is significantly inferior to that of Scotland, England and Wales. (URS Scott Wilson, 2012)

Physical inactivity costs the Irish exchequer €1.6 billion per year. (Cullen, 2010) Changing the land access laws could help to reduce these costs by increasing recreational walking.
 
Referenced from 'Open for Jobs – the case for modernizing Ireland’s land access law'.
 
 

If you build it...

That demand for access to the countryside has never been greater is not in question. Wherever access is made possible, where an attractive piece or countryside is opened, or a corridor through the country is made available, then people will flock to it.

That thought struck me when we recently visited the Newry Canal Trail at Scarva. Walkers, runners, and cyclists were out in there hundreds enjoying the canal towpath. As a result, the cafe at Scarva Visitor's Centre was doing a roaring trade.

One has to ask would it be doing such great business if the canal trail was not there to attract all those people in the first place? Not likely. And one can only wonder what other economic opportunities are being missed out on where such access to the countryside does not exist.

An idea whose time has come...

Well done to Robert Dowds, TD. The logic of the argument is unquestionable.

http://www.kildarestreet.com/debates/?id=2013-06-14a.5


Saturday, 15 June 2013

Devon Coast to Coast

We're just back from walking the devon Coast to Coast walk. Starting at Wembury Beach in South Devon and finishing at Lynmouth on the north coast, its a great walk incorporating as it does the Two Moors Way and the Erme-Plym Trail (the first day of walking and the bit that links the south coast to the start of the Two Moors Way at Ivybridge). It took us 6 days, averaging around 16 or 17 miles per day. Some days were longer than others of course, and the last day came in at around 19.


The countryside is amazing of course, expecially Dartmoor and Exmoor. What's also amazing, for someone who lives in Northern Ireland at any rate, is the fact that the countryside is just so accessible. So many paths, so much open country where you are free to just roam, safe in the knowledge that you have the right to do so. It is little wonder that activity tourism generates so much money for the local economy. All the way along the Coast to Coast trail a thriving tourist trade has developed. B&Bs, country farm house accommodation, taxi services, luggage transfer, package tour operators, all only really exist because the trail exists in the first place.

The lack of political will to improve the access situation in Northern Ireland continues to inhibit such economic opportunities for similar rural communities here.

Saturday, 30 March 2013

Keep Ireland Open

I've been following the Keep Ireland Open website (http://www.keepirelandopen.org)  for a number of years now. They campaign for better countryside access in the Republic of Ireland. They have a tough job on their hands and I wish them well.

I've sometimes thought that some of their rhetoric to be, well, a little whiney, a little negative, and often downright confrontational and abrasive.  I can't really blame them, because the situation 'down south' is pretty dire from a countryside access point of view and it must be downright frustrating to be (or at least appear to be) that lone voice crying in the wilderness.

However, perhaps a change of tactics are in order. Instead of simply complaining about the poor legislative framework and general all round lack of access, I've always thought they would be better spending their time building relationships with those who would benefit from an overhaul of the countryside access laws. It shouldn't take too long to realise who these groups are. A long term strategy to change hearts and minds is what will eventually tip the balance politically.

Of course to do all this requires getting your facts straight, and making sure the story you tell is a convincing and compelling one. An idea can be overwhelmingly powerful, but only if it makes sense, if it has logic and right on its side. To this end, its good to see them listing some nice stats on their Spring 2013 newletter. Keep it up guys, and start thinking about that strategy.

White Easter

Managed to squeeze a quick walk in yesterday around Hillsborough Forest Park. I like this forest, its got a nice feel to it, even if it is rather small. Nice lake, castle grounds, mixture of coniferous and native broadleaves. There is still a lot of snow hanging around as you can see from the picture. The temp was around 2 or 3 degrees at best and its not forecast to get much better over the next couple weeks. Brrr!

Saturday, 2 March 2013

National Trust -

I wasn't feeling great this weekend (man flu), so we went this morning for a short walk at Mount Stewart on the shores of Stangford Lough, a National Trust property. Impressive mansion, nice gardens, short forest walks, that sort of thing. Its nice, pleasant, good to have around. However, I just can't escape the feeling that its completely inaccessible.

Inaccessible how? Its set within the wider context of some very nice countryside. Rolling hills, forest, fields and hedgerows - every single acre of which is completely off-limits to ordinary oiks like myself - and you. Unless you enjoy walking along a busy A-grade road as a pleasant experience, then you really shouldn't try walking to Mount Stewart. No paths or bridleways lead to it. Also, no matter where you walk in Mount Stewart you're going to eventually come across a 'No Access' sign. This is wrong, perverse; an equivalent property in England would be totally connected path-wise to the rest of the landscape. Access there is taken as a given

Don't get me wrong, the Trust do great work. As well as conserving great buildings, they maintain large tracts of countryside, and keep most of it open for access all year round. In the relative desert of access that is the Northern ireland countryside, they have developed many little oasis of accessibility. Divis and Black Mountain, North Antrim Coast, Fair Head, Slieve Donard, Castle Coole to name but a few.

But it strikes me as odd that the Trust, one of the UKs most powerful environmental campaigning organisations, and one supposedly committed to increasing access to the countryside, has never (to the best of my knowledge) addressed Northern Ireland's poor countryside access situation. Why not?





Sunday, 17 February 2013

Newtownabbey Way

We walked the newly opened Newtownabbey Way recently. Lovely trail, for both walkers and cyclists alike, and with plenty of surprises (the viaducts are astonishing). Kudos to Newtownabbey council for having the vision to create such a great amenity - please pay attention everyone else.

Being that it disects essentially urban and suburban areas, its success should be well assured, but it will need to be maintained - litter as always is going to be a problem from certain anti-social types out there.

It links up with the Loughshore Trail, providing an off-road experience all the way to Belfast, Joining up with the Lagan Towpath.







http://www.newtownabbey.gov.uk/maps/newtownabbeyway.asp